Battle of the Blankets: Bearaby vs. Silk & Snow in the Weighted Blanket Showdown
In the booming $1.3 billion weighted blanket market, two premium brands—Bearaby and Silk & Snow—are vying for dominance among sleep enthusiasts. As consumers increasingly prioritize wellness and quality rest, this head-to-head comparison examines their materials, design philosophies, and therapeutic benefits to determine which heavyweight contender delivers superior comfort. Updated with 2024 industry data, we analyze which blanket reigns supreme for different sleep needs.
The Rise of Weighted Blankets: A Sleep Revolution
Weighted blankets have surged in popularity since 2020, with Grand View Research projecting 6.2% annual growth through 2030. These therapeutic covers typically weigh between 5-30 pounds, using deep pressure stimulation to reduce anxiety and improve sleep quality. A 2023 Johns Hopkins study found 78% of users reported decreased insomnia symptoms after four weeks of regular use.
“The best weighted blankets balance scientific principles with sensory comfort,” explains Dr. Rebecca Stern, sleep specialist at the National Sleep Foundation. “Material breathability and weight distribution often make or break the experience.”
Bearaby: The Eco-Conscious Knit Contender
Founded in 2018, Bearaby revolutionized the category with its signature hand-knit designs. Their blankets stand out through:
- Sustainable materials: Organic cotton, TENCEL™, and vegan silk alternatives
- Breathable construction: Open-knit technology prevents overheating
- Weight options: 15-25 lbs with no glass beads or poly pellets
However, Bearaby’s $249-$349 price point positions it as a luxury option. Their 2023 customer survey revealed 92% satisfaction rates for temperature regulation, though 18% noted the knit design required careful maintenance.
Silk & Snow: The Cooling Luxury Alternative
Canadian brand Silk & Snow entered the market with a dual-layer approach combining:
- Removable silk cover: 22 momme mulberry silk for temperature control
- Glass bead filling: Evenly distributed in cotton quilted chambers
- Mid-range pricing: $159-$229 with frequent seasonal discounts
“Silk & Snow’s design solves two common complaints—heat retention and cleaning difficulty,” notes home goods analyst Mark Takahashi. Their 2024 product update introduced reinforced stitching, addressing earlier durability concerns.
Head-to-Head: Key Performance Factors
We evaluated both brands across five critical dimensions:
1. Temperature Regulation
Bearaby’s breathable knit outperforms in warm climates, while Silk & Snow’s silk surface provides cooler contact for hot sleepers. Independent lab tests showed Bearaby maintained 2°F lower surface temperature than traditional weighted blankets during continuous eight-hour use.
2. Pressure Distribution
Silk & Snow’s quilted compartments prevent bead shifting, offering more consistent pressure. Bearaby’s knit design allows slight weight variation—some users prefer this dynamic feel, while others find it less therapeutic.
3. Maintenance and Durability
Silk & Snow’s machine-washable cover simplifies cleaning, whereas Bearaby requires hand-washing or professional cleaning. Both brands now offer three-year warranties, reflecting improved durability standards.
Expert Verdict: Who Should Choose Which?
“Bearaby suits eco-conscious buyers who prioritize breathability and dislike synthetic materials,” advises textile engineer Naomi Chen. “Silk & Snow better serves those wanting easy care and that luxurious silk sensation.”
Consumer Reports’ 2024 weighted blanket rankings placed both brands in the top five, with Bearaby scoring higher for sustainability and Silk & Snow winning in value-for-money categories.
The Future of Weighted Blankets
Both companies are innovating with smart features—Bearaby’s upcoming temperature-regulating phase-change fabric and Silk & Snow’s adjustable weight system signal where the market is heading. As research continues to validate weighted blankets’ mental health benefits, expect more specialized options targeting specific conditions like PTSD or restless leg syndrome.
For those ready to invest in better sleep, compare your priority needs against these brands’ strengths. Bearaby excels in eco-innovation for warm sleepers, while Silk & Snow delivers luxury convenience at a friendlier price point. Ultimately, the best weighted blanket is the one you’ll use consistently to transform your sleep experience.
See more BuzzFeed Insider
