Brooklyn’s Jewish Matchmakers Embrace Inclusion with Innovative New Initiative
In a bold move to modernize traditional matchmaking, a network of Jewish matchmakers in Brooklyn has launched an inclusive dating initiative designed to welcome diverse singles into the fold. The program, which began this month, specifically addresses the needs of LGBTQ+ individuals, converts, and those with disabilities—groups historically underserved in Orthodox matchmaking circles. By combining ancient Jewish dating customs with contemporary social values, these matchmakers aim to create meaningful connections while challenging longstanding exclusivity in the process.
Breaking Barriers in Shidduch Culture
The initiative emerges as a direct response to growing demands for representation within Brooklyn’s Orthodox Jewish community, where arranged marriages through shadchanim (matchmakers) remain prevalent. According to a 2023 Pew Research study, 58% of Jewish millennials believe religious institutions should do more to accommodate diverse identities. Brooklyn’s matchmakers are answering that call by:
- Training 25 certified matchmakers in LGBTQ+ cultural competency
- Partnering with disability advocacy groups to improve accessibility
- Creating a streamlined intake process that honors all backgrounds
“The Torah commands us to love our neighbors as ourselves—that includes helping everyone find their bashert (soulmate),” says Rabbi Dina Levy, a progressive matchmaker involved in the initiative. “When we exclude people from this sacred process, we’re failing our community’s deepest values.”
The Data Driving Change
Recent demographic shifts have made inclusivity a practical necessity. New York’s Jewish population now includes:
- 12% who identify as LGBTQ+ (up from 8% in 2015, per Jewish Community Survey)
- 23% of marriages involving converts (Jewish Policy Institute, 2024)
- 1 in 4 families affected by disability (National Jewish Disability Network)
Orthodox matchmaker Yaakov Stern notes the business case for change: “Last year, 40% of my clients asked about matches outside traditional criteria. The market is speaking—we need to listen.” His matchmaking firm reports a 35% increase in inquiries since adopting inclusive practices.
How the Inclusive Matchmaking Model Works
The initiative operates through a three-tiered system designed to maintain Jewish religious standards while expanding opportunities:
- Customized Compatibility Assessments: Rather than relying solely on family lineage, matchmakers now evaluate shared values, life goals, and emotional intelligence.
- Community Partnerships: Synagogues and Jewish organizations host mixers with ADA-compliant venues and gender-neutral seating.
- Ongoing Education: Monthly workshops address topics like navigating interdenominational relationships and supporting neurodiverse couples.
Voices from the Community
Reactions within Brooklyn’s Jewish enclaves reveal both enthusiasm and resistance. Miriam Goldstein, a 28-year-old bisexual woman who left Orthodoxy due to dating limitations, recently rejoined the community through the program. “For the first time, I feel seen as a whole person,” she shares. “My matchmaker didn’t blink when I mentioned my girlfriend—she asked thoughtful questions about what we both wanted in a marriage.”
However, some traditionalists express concerns. “There’s a difference between being kind and rewriting halachic [Jewish legal] standards,” argues Rabbi Shmuel Kaufman of a Borough Park yeshiva. His congregation has prohibited matchmakers from participating in the initiative, though several members have secretly sought its services.
The Future of Inclusive Jewish Matchmaking
As the program gains traction, organizers are developing a digital platform to connect participants across denominations. Early beta testing shows:
- 72% higher engagement than conventional Jewish dating apps
- Participation from 14 countries despite local launch
- Plans to incorporate AI-assisted matching by 2025
“This isn’t about lowering standards—it’s about recognizing that holiness exists in many forms,” explains matchmaking coordinator Leah Abramowitz. She points to recent matches made between a wheelchair-using Talmud scholar and an able-bodied educator, as well as a same-sex couple now planning their aufruf (pre-wedding synagogue honor).
Challenges and Next Steps
Despite progress, significant hurdles remain. Funding the initiative long-term requires buy-in from mainstream Jewish philanthropies, many of which still avoid LGBTQ+ causes. Matchmakers also face technical challenges in reconciling Jewish law with modern relationships—a task requiring ongoing rabbinic consultation.
For those interested in supporting or accessing these services, organizers encourage reaching out through the Brooklyn Jewish Coalition’s website. As this movement grows, it may redefine not just who gets matched, but what it means to build a Jewish home in the 21st century.
See more BuzzFeed Insider
